Cutco Knife Review: Is It Really Worth the Price?
No other tool is as important to professional chefs as their knives. Chefs will carry their own knife cases back and forth from home to work to make sure nothing happens to their knives. They take great care to hand wash and dry their good knives. They hone them after every use so they are always ready for the next task. Home cooks quickly discover the difference good knives make when they have the luxury of quality knives. This Cutco knife review will evaluate an established line of knives designed for home use and compare it to sets from other brands.
What Is the Cutco Brand of Knives?
Cutco knives are manufactured in Olean, New York. The company was founded there in 1949 and has been located there manufacturing a wide range of cutlery for home and professional kitchens. The company prides itself on the high quality of the materials and design of its products, the loyalty and professionalism of its large staff, and its vigorously enforced lifetime warranty program. Of its 600 employees more than 200 have been with the company for 20 years or more. This Cutco Knife Review features the Cutco 8-Piece Kitchen Knife Set, just one product in this extensive brand.
Although the company now sells its products through Amazon.com and has about 15 retail outlets, its original and primary business model has been independent sales representatives who provide one-on-one demonstrations of the products and are the main point of contact for Cutco customers.
Cutco knives are made of quality high-carbon 440A stainless steel. The knives have a full tang. The blades are hollow-ground, heat-treated and mirror-polished. The blades are designed to be strong, flexible and durable. The knife handles are ergonomically designed to fit naturally and comfortably in the user’s hand. They are designed to be well-balanced and have the solid construction that makes a knife both comfortable to hold and safe to use. Cutco makes an extensive variety of kitchen knives, steak knives, scissors, and sport knives. Cutco knives may be purchased separately or in a variety of sets.
The four knife sets in this Cutco Knife Review are all high-quality sets from highly-regarded brands. They range from around the average price rang all the way to the expensive range. The price rating reflects where the set is priced in comparison to the others in this Cutco knife review.
How the Cutco Set Compares
For this Cutco Knife Review we selected a few similar knife sets available on the market to see how they compare.
Ease of Use
These sharp knives are ready to use. The Cutco website has excellent information on the care and use of the knives as well as information on developing knife skills, recipes and other helpful tips.
Cutco prides itself on its high-quality product. Its mirror-polished, hollow-ground blades are heat-tempered. Critics of the line attack the brand as being stamped instead of forged. But the process used creates a finished product that competes successfully with many of the world’s best forged blades. Cutco knives are noted for holding their sharp edge. Owners rave about the Cutco shears which, like the knives, are backed by the Cutco Forever Guarantee.
The Cutco warranty is in a league of its own and sometimes even referred to as the legendary Cutco Forever Guarantee. There is a 15-day satisfaction guarantee that offers a full refund if the customer is not satisfied with the purchase in the first 15 days. The guarantee covers the knife set for its lifetime, even when it’s handed down to the next generation. This is an established company that plans to be around to respond to requests for service for generations to come. Cutco users rave about the customer service. The company offers sharpening services on multiple knives per order at very reasonable rates.
- 2.75″ Parer; 4″ Parer/Utility; 5″ Serrated Utility; 5″ Santoku HE; 8″ Chef; Block with Steak Slots; Kitchen Shears; 9″ Steel
- Manufactured in Germany
- Special formula high carbon NO STAIN steel
- SIGMAFORGE knife is forged from a single piece of solid steel
- Ice-hardened FRIODUR blade starts sharper, stays sharper longer, and has superior resilience
This Zwilling J. A. Henckels 8-Piece Knife Set includes a 2.75-inch parer, 4-inch parer/utility knife, 5-inch serrated utility knife, 5-inch Santoku, 8-inch chef’s knife, kitchen shears, 9-inch honing steel and block with additional slots for steak knives. This Twin Four Star II Series is the company’s best selling knife series worldwide. These knives are manufactured in Germany of special formula high carbon steel. They are forged from a single piece of solid steel and ice hardened, producing their FRIODUR blade. The handles are ergonomically designed and made of polypropylene permanently bonded to the blade.
The knives are hot-drop forged by hand from a single blank of high carbon no-stain steel, a specially alloyed surgical steel consisting of exact proportions of carbon, chromium, molybdenum, and vanadium. The blades are tapered from bolster to tip and from the back of the blades to the edges and are honed by hand. The tang extends through the length of the knife. The stainless steel end cap is marked with the ZWILLING J.A. Henckels logo.
Ease of Use
These popular knives are designed for comfort and balance, making them efficient tools and easy to work with right from the start.
These handsome knives are well-shaped and hand honed. This brand has loyal fans who appreciate the logo embedded in the stainless steel endcap.
There seems to be a lifetime limited warranty on these knives, but the warranty is not a marketing tool for this company. As an international company they indicate that their warranty policies differ and recommend contacting the company with issues as they arise.
- Outstanding craftsmanship, cutting-edge technology, stunning design elements, and premium materials. Peak performance has never looked so good at this price.
- Incredibly razor sharp, full-tang, imported high-carbon German steel with a hand polished edge at 14-16 degrees per side. Precisely tempered and stain resistant. This set will last a lifetime.
- Award winning design, with satisfying heft, premium materials and quality feel.
This Dalstrong Gladiator 8-Piece Knife Set includes 8-inch chef’s knife, 7-inch Santoku knife, 9-inch bread knife, 9-inch carving/slicer, 6.5-inch utility knife, 6-inch serrated utility knife, 3.5-inch paring knife, 8-inch Gladiator Series honing steel and block. The blades are precision-forged, ultra sharp, and wear resistant. Each blade is made from a single-piece of high carbon ThyssenKrupp. Each knife has a full tang. Handles are made from laminated Pakkawood imported from Spain.
Ease of Use
These knives are highly regarded by kitchen professionals who appreciate the high quality Dalstrong product and also the reasonable price point of this line. These knives are favorites of people who know what they are doing and will be able to pick up one of these handsome tools and put it to work.
These Dalstrong knives have tall blade height, a feature that allows for good knuckle clearance for comfortable and efficient use. The bolster is designed with additional heft to enhance the knife’s balance and has a mirror finish. Appearance is important to Dalstrong and the company boasts of the “beautifully rounded curves, acute angles and precise visual symmetry” of this knife series.
The Dalstrong Company, like the Cutco Company, leads its promotional information with an emphasis on their lifetime warranty, satisfaction guarantee and strong customer service backing up those pledges.
- Wusthof Knife Set Includes: 3.5″ Paring Knife, 4.5″ Utility Knife, 8″ Chef’s Knife, 9″ Double Serrated Bread Knife, 9″ Sharpening Steel, Come-Apart Kitchen Shears, 9-slot Acacia Knife Block
- Blade is precision forged, tempered to 58 Rockwell Hardness
- 14° PEtec blade edge on each side with laser guided precision; 20% sharper lasting twice as long
This Wusthof 7-Piece Class Knife Block Set includes an 8-inch chef’s knife, 6-inch carving/sandwich knife, 8-inch bread-knife, 4.5-inch paring knife, 3-inch vegetable knife, 9-inch honing steel and kitchen shears in a seven-slot black ash wood block.
The knife blades are precision hot-drop forged from a single blank of high-carbon stainless steel consisting of exacting proportions of carbon, chromium, molybdenum, and vanadium. The blades are perfectly tapered from bolster to tip, and from the back of the blades to the edges, and are honed by hand. The durable handle is made of Hostaform-C which is triple-riveted to the fully visible tang. The handle is hand-polished and buffed.
People who purchase this set are enthusiastic about the quality of the knives and the kitchen shears. Complaints seem to focus on issues with the block, both with the slots and with issues with the finish. The logos on the handles are stickers and not permanent.
Wusthof has a Lifetime Limited Warranty against defects in materials and workmanship. Their warranty information has a number of disclaimers and doesn’t cover handles and blocks made of wood. Although the language of the warranty seems aimed at protecting the company, assuming they stand behind the warranty it should be good.
Cutco Knife Review Conclusion
This Cutco knife review tackles a challenging question about the value of this expensive knife set. A really good set of knives is an investment. Cutco helps justify the initial expense of one of their sets with the solid backing of their Forever Guarantee. This has been an important selling point for this company. Just as much as the customer is buying quality equipment, they are buying the backing of a company that is pledging to repair or replace their knives for the life of the product.
Unique Distribution System – The Personal Touch
The company now offers its knives through Amazon.com and through Cutco 15 retail outlets, but their main distribution system has been and continues to be independent sales representatives who demonstrate the product to their customers and communicate the value of the brand and its guarantee. These personal relationships have built a strong network of loyal Cutco customers. The Cutco target audience is the home cook who wants to have good equipment backed by a company that cares about them and their knives, and who is willing to pay for this luxury.
Website Creates Sense of Cutco Community
The Cutco website is powerful evidence of what this company is all about. They are proud of their product. They are proud of their employees. They care about their customers. And they want to provide a sense of community for the network of home cooks who are using Cutco knives. The website is full of helpful information for the home cook, including tips on knife skills and recipes.
More Than Just Knives
The four knife sets featured in this Cutco knife review all have their strengths and their fans. Professional chefs favor other brands than Cutco. Objectively the Cutco product seems expensive compared to the other excellent sets in this comparison. But even the lowest priced in this group represents an investment. We give the Cutco knife set 4 stars on a five star rating system. And we answer the question “Is It Really Worth the Price?” with a more subjective answer. Cutco customers feel they are buying more than a knife set. Cutco works hard to provide added value to their product and customers seem willing to pay for that.
Featured Image from Amazon